5: The Platts

Grave of Elizabeth Platt

Elizabeth Platt had had a very difficult life when she died at the age of 49 on March 20, 1878. She and her husband, Harry, buried three daughters in the graveyard, all younger than one year old. Ten-month-old Emma Maria had died on August 4, 1853. Six-month-old Phebe Elizabeth died on August 4, 1859. And on September 28, 1862, an unnamed daughter died at the age of 22 days.

I have good reason to believe that Elizabeth Platt was the same person as the Elizabeth Sarles listed in the 1850 census. Elizabeth Sarles is the right age to be Elizabeth Platt and lived in the same town. Sarles is the most common surname in the graveyard (accounting for 61 out of 419 surnames). Lastly, and perhaps most convincingly, Elizabeth Sarles had a brother named Schuyler, the same name as Elizabeth Platt's son.

If this is true, then Elizabeth's parents were most likely William and Maria Sarles, who are buried in the cemetery. They died in 1858 (age 84) and 1842 (age 48), respectively. Elizabeth's brothers Schuyler and Erastus are also buried in the cemetery. Erastus died in 1862 at the age of 29 and Schuyler died in 1867 at the age of 37.

1850 US Federal Census

In 1860, Harry, a mason, and Elizabeth Platt were recorded living with their three sons, Hickson, William, and Schuyler.

1860 US Federal Census

Harry and Elizabeth's daughter Evelyn would be born about a year after this census. She seems to be the first of their daughters to have lived past infancy. However, she died at age 18, less than a year after Elizabeth's death, and was buried beside her mother.

Grave of Evelyn Platt

About a year after Evelyn's death, the surviving Platts were living together with two housekeepers. William Platt had been living with another family in the 1870 census, working as a farmhand. However, he had returned to the Platts' by this time and was working as a railway agent.

1880 US Federal Census

Harry was working as a plasterer. His son Hickson was working as ... a minister? I can't quite make out what it says on the census.

This census identifies a second daughter of the Platts who survived her infancy - Lizzie, who was born around 1869. Ultimately, the Platts seem to have had eight children: four who died young and were buried in the cemetery, and four who lived to adulthood.

Of those who lived, Hickson Platt, who was obviously named with a genealogist's interest in mind, was widowed relatively young. In 1900 and 1910, he was living with a woman named Emily Terry in the Middle River Center District in Danbury, Connecticut, and working as a hired man.

In 1917, the 61-year-old Hickson was interviewed for the Connecticut Military Census by Charles Brundage. Among other things, the interview established that Hickson could ride a horse, but not drive a car; he was a good swimmer, and stood 5'3" tall. It also established that Charles Brundage couldn't spell "widower," even when the correct spelling was right in front of him.

1917 Connecticut Military Census for Hickson Platt

Hickson's brother William married a woman named Eudora around 1889, and in 1900 was working at a candy store in Aspen, Colorado. William and Eudora lived with her mother Esther Burroughs, her brother Sam, and two boarders.

1900 US Federal Census

Ten years later, 87-year-old Harry had come to live with William and Eudora in Aspen, along with William's niece and nephew, Eudora and Fred Sarles, and a boarder who worked at the candy store.

1910 US Federal Census

By 1920, Harry had presumably died. William, who still worked at the candy store, and Eudora lived with the younger Eudora and one boarder.

1920 US Federal Census

The younger Eudora stayed in Aspen and married Paul R. Caley, a county assessor. In 1940, Paul was listed by the census as "unable to work." Eudora was working as an accountant for the Works Progress Administration. Paul's younger brother Arbing, who lived with them, was employed as a miner.

An investigation into the older Eudora's early life revealed something surprising. She was a Sarles too! Actually, I'm not sure it's that surprising. William's niece and nephew were Sarleses, after all.

1880 US Federal Census

In 1880 Eudora's mother Esther was married to Joseph Burroughs and living in Kent, Connecticut. Eudora, age 18, was working as a teacher.

I assume that Esther Burroughs is the same person as the Hester Sarles listed in the 1860 census, with Eudora yet to be born. And yes, Hamilton Sarles is buried in the cemetery, of course. He died on June 1, 1869, at the age of 43.

1860 US Federal Census

 As for Schuyler Platt, he married a woman named Caroline, and was working as a "tobacconist" in 1880 and living at 336 West 22 Street in Manhattan. In 1886, he enlisted in the army. In the register of enlistments, he is described as 27 years old, a salesman, 5'4" tall, with a dark complexion, brown eyes, and black hair.

1886 Enlistment Registration of Schuyler Platt

Unfortunately, it's very difficult for me to say what happened to the youngest Platt, Lizzie. There are just too many Elizabeths who were born around 1869 for me to determine who and if she married. Of course, I could probably find out what happened to her if I was doing serious genealogy, i.e. the type of genealogy that requires me to leave my house. If and when that happens I'll probably end up doing follow-up reports on all of the people I've covered so far.

4: Charles and Deborah Haight

Grave of Charles Haight

While Gilbert Marten may be the longest lived person buried in the cemetery, Charles Haight may be the oldest, having died on October 3, 1799, at the age of 88 years and 1 month, placing his birth somewhere in September 1711; he was born in Rye, New York, the son of Jonathan Haight and Rebecca Gannung. (His death and age were inscribed on his gravestone, which has since deteriorated considerably. Fortunately a transcription was made in 1914.)

Charles Haight is also remarkable among the people of the cemetery for another reason. A farmer,* he once owned the land that the cemetery now occupies. He donated it to the Episcopal Church in 1761, and they built a small wooden church. That building was damaged during the Revolutionary War, when it served as a hospital for soldiers, and was torn down in 1819. The photograph below shows the church that was built in 1850, which is now gone as well. (This post shows a picture of the inside of the Episcopalian Church that exists today.)

Episcopalian Church built 1850

Not surprisingly, Charles also served as a vestryman and warden of the church. His father Jonathan was a Quaker, although he is mentioned as "on Episcopal Church records 1752," according to the Genung Genealogy. I don't know if this means he converted or, like me, was a Quaker who just liked hanging out in the Episcopalian Church sometimes.

Grave of Charles Haight

Charles's mother Rebecca was a granddaughter of Jean Guenon, a Huguenot who married into a Dutch family. Her parents were Jeremiah and Martha Gannung. Her father, who was baptized in the Reformed Dutch Church in Manhattan, moved to Westchester in the 1720s.

Charles married Deborah Sutton, who was born around 1714, in 1734 in Hempstead, New York. They had three known children: Charles Jr., James, and Hannah. None of them are buried in the cemetery. Deborah, however, is buried next to Charles, having died on November 23, 1793 at the age of 78. Her grave is in much better condition than her husband's.

Grave of Deborah Sutton Haight

Both graves are notable for being two of the fourteen sandstone markers in the cemetery. Eighteenth-century sandstone graves in New York and New England are probably my favorite type of American gravestones. I didn't see any when I was in England, but a reliable source suggests that they are there too, and presumably before they were here. They're just remarkable. The faces are primitive, yet exhibit endless variation. As one person pointed out to me, the design around the angel head on Charles Haight's grave is like the sun's rays.

There are a lot sadder stories in the graveyard than Charles Haight's, but there are few sadder gravestones. Surely the stone of the man who gave the Episcopalian Church its first home in the town deserves better than to have his last monument crumble away. Eventually, sure, they'll all crumble away, but we can certainly fix some of the damage for the moment.

There are two other Haights buried in the cemetery, both very small children. I've yet to determine how (if at all) they're related to Charles. There are Haights all over the county, many of them Quakers.

The first is Nicholas Haight, the son of Nicholas Haight and Jemima Halstead, who died on June 8, 1791, at the age of three months and 21 days.

The second is James C. Haight, the son of Stephen P. and Mary S. Haight, who died on April 22, 1850, at age two years, one month, and seventeen days.


*On the plaque in front of the cemetery, he is identified as "Charles Haight, Esq." In the U.S. today "Esq." after a person's name indicates that he is a lawyer, but apparently in the past it was simply a way of acknowledging someone of high rank (and perhaps this is still true in the U.K.?).

Sources
Nichols, Mary Josephine Genung and Leon Nelson Nichols. Genung, Ganong, Ganung Genealogy: A History of the Descendants of Jean Guenon of Flushing, Long Island. Brooklyn, NY: A. W. Heinrich's Printing Company, 1906.

3: Gilbert Marten

Grave of Gilbert Marten

Gilbert Marten is the longest-lived person buried in the cemetery.* When he died on June 16, 1854, he was 90 years, six months, and eighteen days old. His headstone is notable for its plainness; it's almost unfinished looking, but handsome and well-preserved. Its simplicity made me wonder if Gilbert was a Quaker (there are a handful buried in the cemetery, including Enoch Greene's wife Phebe).

The 1800 census only records the names of householders, while simply enumerating the other members of the household. From this record I know that 36-year-old Gilbert Marten, resident in the same town he was buried in, was living in a household with six white males and four white females (two over the age of 25, presumably Gilbert and his wife) and five slaves. Yes, slaves! Slavery wasn't abolished in New York State until 1827.

Although some Quakers did own slaves in the early Colonial Era, Quakers soon became fiercely anti-slavery and were prominent abolitionists - so I think it's pretty safe to say that Gilbert Marten was not a Quaker.** Of the other households listed on the census page with Gilbert Marten's, only one other household had slaves (and only one slave). I wonder what Gilbert's neighbors, many of whom would have been Quakers, thought of him. 

1800 US Federal Census

Fifty years later, Gilbert was living with John Matthews, age 20; George Matthews, age 16; and Mary Baum, age 18. What was his relation to them? Notably, Gilbert is the only one whose "value of property" is recorded. His property is valued at $10,000 (something like $260,000 today). Perhaps the three young people worked for him?

1850 US Federal Census

I haven't been able to determine if Gilbert Marten was related to the seven Martins buried in the cemetery. Nor have I been able to identify his wife or children (as mentioned, they are enumerated, but not named, in the census). I probably could if I did more in-depth research, like actually looking up the old Episcopalian records; I'll likely do this at some point, but after I've accumulated information on a lot more other people buried in the cemetery. For now, I can say with some certainty that Gilbert Marten was at one time probably one of the oldest and richest members of this community.


*That is, before 1914. I'm going from a transcript made at that time. A handful of people were buried in the cemetery after 1914, but I think it's fair to assume that they probably didn't live past 90. I could be wrong.

** Transcripts are most useful when you read them, which I learned after double checking the listing for Marten and realizing it already said he was an Episcopalian.

2: Ann M. Shamp

Ann M. Shamp, wife of James C., died on March 4, 1863, at the age of 26. My first task was to connect her, the only person with the surname Shamp in the cemetery, to the other graves. The answer was clear as soon as I found her death record in the collection of Massachusetts Town and Vital Records (she died in Springfield, MA). Of course she would be a Searles, the most common name in the cemetery.

Springfield, MA death record of Ann Shamp

Ann's brother Theodore, who had died two years earlier at age 21, is also buried in the cemetery, but their parents, Hiram and Ellen, are not.

Three years prior to her death from consumption, Ann was living in Westchester, New York, with her husband James, who was born in Wooster, Ohio, their baby daughter Mary, and Ann's sister Henrietta.

1860 US Federal Census

What had brought Ann to Massachusetts? It seems that she and James had moved there. In 1870, he was still living in Springfield, with his second wife Elmira, his and Ann's daughter Mary, and two sons. He worked as a superintendant at a cemetery. James's son Joseph, who was born around 1862, is plausibly Ann's son. There is a large gap in age between him and his (presumed) half-brother, Walter.

The one question is, whose daughter is Lillian? If she is Ann's, why wasn't she listed in the 1860 census?

1870 US Federal Census

The answer is provided by James and Elmira's marriage record. The couple was married on June 30, 1864, in Chicopee, MA. It was the second marriage for both of them. Although I've been unable to identify Elmira's first husband, presumably Lillian was hers from a former marriage.

James and Elmira's marriage record, Chicopee, MA

Springfield, MA in 1879

 Ten years later, in the 1880 census, James is still in Springfield, still working at the cemetery, but is living with a third wife, Nancy, along with Mary, Joseph, and Walter.

1880 US Federal Census

Thanks to Massachusetts's impeccable records, I was able to find that James and Nancy M. Knight were married on April 3, 1878, in Springfield, when he was 42 and she was 34. The record also lists James's parents, Andrew and Eliza Shamp, and Nancy's father, Asa M. Knight.

James and Nancy's marriage record, Springfield, MA

James died in Springfield on February 9, 1887, at the age of 50, of rheumatism (rheumatic fever?).

James Shamp's death record, Springfield, MA

James and Nancy didn't have children together. In 1900, she was living in Springfield with her sister, Rebecca Knight.

1900 US Federal Census

Meanwhile, Ann and James's daughter Mary married Robert M. West, a carpenter who was born in Nova Scotia, on March 15, 1882, in Boston.

Robert and Mary's marriage record, Boston, MA

Robert and Mary had one daughter, Anna, who was born in July 1881, or possibly 1882 or 1883, depending on which census you believe.

1900 US Federal Census

In 1910, Anna was married to Charlie H. Sibley, a railway machinist, and the couple were living with Robert and Mary at 50 Clifton Avenue in Springfield.

1910 US Federal Census

Ten years later Anna, age 37, was a widow and the owner of a house with three boarders at 60 Clifton Avenue. Her parents were still at 50 Clifton Avenue, and were still there in 1930, while Anna had moved to 267 Dwight Street Extension. After that, I lose track of them.

1920 US Federal Census

So there you have it. Three generations, beginning with the tragic death of Ann Shamp when she was 26, and ending with her granddaughter Anna being widowed in her thirties. James Shamp lost two wives, only to leave his third wife a young widow. It seems that only Ann's daughter Mary was the only person who was able to experience a long married life.

1: Dr. Enoch and Phebe Greene

Grave of Phebe Greene and her children

This is the first post in what I hope will be an extensive project, which I'm calling the Episcopalian Cemetery Project. I'll pick a gravestone (or two) from the cemetery, and see what information I can find out about the people based on some basic genealogical research.

I was drawn to this pair of gravestones first because of their sadness. There are a lot of young children buried in this cemetery, along with young mothers, fathers, sisters, etc., but the story behind these graves is that of the total annihilation of this small family within a few years. Five souls are buried beneath these two stones.

Grave of Enoch Greene, MD

Enoch Greene, M.D., as he is identified on his stone, was born in Weare, New Hampshire, on October 29, 1820, the son of Moses Greene and Betty Johnson. He was presumably named for his grandfather, Betty's father, Enoch Johnson. He attended the Clinton Grove Academy, the Nine Partners' Friends' School in Dutchess County, NY, and the Medical University of New York (now NYU School of Medicine).

In his early career, Enoch worked as a physician at Bellevue Hospital and Blackwell's Island Hospital in New York. In May 1845, he moved to New Castle, in Westchester County, where he began his own private practice, and "very soon gathered a large circle of patients and friends," according to The History of Weare, NH.

On June 25 of that year, he married Phebe Hoag Chase, a Quaker who was born in Weare to John Chase and Betty Dow in March 1810. An antiques dealer in Philadelphia had a sampler (now sold) that was created by Phebe's first cousin, Mary Gove, under Phebe's instruction (Phebe is credited on the sampler itself as "instructress").

Sampler made by Phebe's cousin Mary Gove

In 1848, Enoch became the medical director of Sing Sing Prison, and, shortly after, the superintendant of the hospitals on Ward's Island, where in the course of his duties he was responsible for saving two dozen child patients from a fire. He was also credited for improving the quality of care for patients with "ship's fever" (typhus), so that the death rates greatly dropped, and for designing and overseeing the construction of several new buildings on the island.

Then, in August 1849, Phebe died of cholera following only a few hours' illness. Buried with her in the cemetery are their son Freddy and "two infants." 

Enoch was forced to resign his position at Ward's Island in January 1850 due to illness, but by November was well enough to begin working again, as chief physician at Kings County Hospital. During this time Enoch was living in Manhattan as a boarder in a house with four other people, one of them a medical student, according to the 1850 Census, taken in August.

1850 US Federal Census

On March 13, 1851, Enoch married again, to Susan Brundage, the daughter of Gilbert Brundage and Mary Merritt, who was born October 13, 1822. Then, on April 24, Enoch died of typhus in Flatbush, Brooklyn. This was the announcement of his death in the New-York Daily Tribune on April 26.

NY Daily Tribune April 26, 1851

By the 1900 Census, Susan - now Susan Horton - had been widowed again. The census states she had no children (living or dead). Her widowed "sister" (who was probably misidentified, judging by the fact that she was 37 and Susan was 78) and "niece" (age 14) were living with her. Susan died on August 13, 1906, and is buried in the Episcopalian Cemetery.

1900 US Federal Census

[Sources]

New York Civil War Photos Project

1. Chester F. Dewey
2. William Carason
3. William Glenny
4. Joseph Egolf
5. Lewis W. Cashdollar 
6. Abram M. Carhart 
7. Lucretia Electa and Louisa Ellen Crossett
8. Alfred A. Stratton 

Cemetery Index

A
Acker, Harry E.
Alford, Ann Powers 
Avery, Nathan C.

B
Babcock, Amos
Babcock, Charles S.
Babcock, Sarah
Babcock, William G.
Baker, Addie Odell
Baker, Benjamin H.
Baker, Duron F. 
Baker, Emeline
Baker, Hester
Baker, Salena A.
Baker, Susan M.
Baker, William
Banks, Susan P.
Beardsley, Emma W. Lester
Beardsley, Mary Emma
Bostwick, Ann Taylor
Bostwick, Maria Proudfoot
Bostwick, Mary Elizabeth (1850-1851)
Bostwick, Mary Elizabeth (1821-1891)
Brady, Anna Boyce
Brady, Edmund B.
Brady, Elijah
Brown, Mary Ann
Brown, William
Brundage, Armenia
Brundage, Elvira Merritt
Brundage, Evalena
Brundage, Gilbert
Brundage, Harry
Brundage, John (1796-1872)
Brundage, John (b. 1848)
Brundage, Maria L.
Brundage, Martha
Brundage, Mary Merritt
Brundage, Merritt
Brundage, Sarah T.
Brundage, Susan
Brundage, Thomas H.
Burnham, Ella
Burnham, Lizzie L.

C
Carpenter, Absalom
Carpenter, Caroline
Carpenter, Charles
Carpenter, Eleanor
Carpenter, Gilbert
Carpenter, Mary A.
Carpenter, Oscar W.
Carpenter, Sarah
Carpenter, William
Cary, Nathan
Cary, William
Chase, Edwin L.
Chase, Hannah
Chase, Phebe Maria
Churchwell, Cornelius
Clark, Bertha J.
Clark, Carrie A.
Clark, Evelinah
Clark, James C.
Clayton, Henry Edgar
Conklin, Jacob (1827-1853)
Conklin, Jacob (1850-1853)
Cooper, [Son of William and Sarah]
Cornell, Ann Maria
Coutant, Alice F.
Craft, Caroline
Craft, Catharine
Craft, Hannah
Craft, Harriet
Craft, Henry Livingston
Craft, John M.
Craft, Robert (1779-1793)
Craft, Robert (1794-1794)
Craft, William
Cronk, Alfred
Cronk, Charles W.
Cronk, Sally A. Carpenter
Cutler, Aramenty
Cutler, John
Cutler, Nathaniel
Cutler, Sarah Ann
Cutler, Stephen

D
Daniels, Frederick E.
Daniels, George
Dean, Caroline Sarles
Dean, Deborah Ann
Dean, Marcus
Dickson, Charles
Dickson, George
Dickson, Margaret
Dutcher, Adaline
Dutcher, Amanda
Dutcher, Benjamin K.
Dutcher, Tillie

E
Essex, Sarah L.

F
Fero, Rev. Thomas E.
Ferris, Rachel
Ferris, Stephen
Ferris, Absalom
Ferris, Cornelius F.
Ferris, James (1761-1826)
Ferris, James (1803-1838)
Ferris, Martha
Ferris, Peter N.
Ferris, Phebe Ward
Ferris, Richard
Fish, Sarah
Fisher, "Little Jessie"
Fisher, Emma
Fisher, Sadie W.
Fisher, Sarah M.
Foshay, Sarah

G
Gilbert, Almira
Gilbert, Catharine F.
Gilbert, Catharine
Gilbert, Joel F.
Gorham, Carrie J.
Gorham, Charles W.
Gorham, George Starr
Gorham, Henry
Gorham, James J.
Gorham, Josie
Gorham, Lillian Harriet
Gorham, Martha J.
Green, Elizabeth
Green, Flora
Green, Howard
Green, John
Green, John
Green, Joshua
Green, Mary
Green, Rebecca A.
Green, William
Greene, [Child of Enoch and Phebe]
Greene, [Child of Enoch and Phebe]
Greene, Dr. Enoch
Greene, Phebe H.

H
Haight, Charles
Haight, Deborah
Haight, James C.
Haight, Mary S.
Haight, Nicholas
Haines, Alexander
Haines, Amy
Haines, Godfrey
Haines, Hannah
Haines, Jerusha
Haines, John D.
Haines, Lyon Miller
Haines, Martha
Haines, Matthew
Haines, Peter
Haines, Phebe E.
Haines, Sarah
Haines, Solomon
Haines, Solomon S.
Hall, Abram V.
Hall, Ann Elizabeth
Hall, Eliza Ann Fish
Hall, Frankie
Hall, Isaac S.
Hall, James Smith
Hall, Mary H. Bower
Hall, Mary S. Haight
Hall, Nancy
Hart, Joseph P.
Hart, N. Coleman
Hart, Nancy
Hart, Reginald
Hart, R. Stewart
Hewlett, Ann
Hewlett, Isaac
Hewlett, Mary
Hewlett, Mary F.
Hewlett, Millard F.
Hewlett, William
Hewlett, William Henry (1832-1837)
Hewlett, William Henry (1849-1849)
Higgins, William
Horton, Susan M.
Hutchings, Esther
Hutchings, Warren

I

J

K 
Kirby, Albert E.
Kirby, Joseph
Kirby, Mary
Kirby, Rachel
Kirby, Richard
Knapp, Frances L.

L
Lands, John
Lane, Albert S.
Lane, Eliza A.
Lane, William H. (1807-1876)
Lane, William H. (1846-1876)
Leggett, Charles E.
Leggett, Esther R. Sands
Leggett, Dr. Joseph
Leggett, Dr. Robert
Leggett, Mary Ann Sands
Leggett, Merritt E.
Lent, Permelia
Lent, Willet
Lent, Zilpha H.
Lester, Lucretia Edwards
Lester, Mary Seaman
Lockwood, Elise B. Cowers
Lockwood, William F.
Lounsbary, Isaac
Lounsberry, Robert
Luckey, Isabella Bird

M
Marten, Gilbert
Martin, Alcha
Martin, Elizabeth
Martin, Esther
Martin, Hester
Martin, John
Martin, John Jr.
Martin, Matilda
Matthews, David J.
Mead, Lewis H.
Mead, William H.
Merritt, Abijah S.
Miller, Elizabeth Doughty
Merritt, Joseph H.
Merritt, Mary L. Haight
Merritt, Nathan
Merritt, Ruth
Miller, Charles H.
Miller, John
Miller, Jonathan
Miller, Monmouth
Miller, Phebe Pine
Miller, Sarah Elizabeth
Miller, Rachel Merritt
Montross, Mary
Montross, Susan
Mosher, "Little Emma"
Mosher, Willie H.
Myers, Amy

N

O
Odell, Johnson

P 
Park, Caroline
Perry, Clarence
Pinkney, John
Pinkney, William
Platt, Elizabeth
Platt, Emma Maria
Platt, Evelyn
Platt, [Daughter of Harry and Elizabeth]
Platt, Phebe Elizabeth
Powers, Ann
Pullis, Major Washington B.
Purdy, Charles H.
Purdy, Deborah
Purdy, Jacob
Purdy, Philander G.
Purdy, Sarah Carpenter

Q

R 
Reynolds, Anna T.
Reynolds, Bethia
Reynolds, Cyrus
Reynolds, Henry F.
Reynolds, Marietta
Reynolds, Matilda
Reynolds, Smith
Rooney, Mary

S
Sands, Cynthia J.
Sands, Elizabeth
Sands, Florence
Sands, Jesse M.
Sands, Josie
Sands, Willie
Sarles, Ann
Sarles, Ann A.
Sarles, Ann Eliza
Sarles, Annet
Sarles, Bailey B.
Sarles, Caroline
Sarles, Caroline G.
Sarles, Catharine G.
Sarles, Eddie
Sarles, Edmund B.
Sarles, Edward B.
Sarles, Elkanah
Sarles, Erastus
Sarles, Esther A.
Sarles, Esther W.
Sarles, Fanny
Sarles, Flora
Sarles, Floyd
Sarles, Hamilton
Sarles, Hannah
Sarles, Harold
Sarles, Henry A.
Sarles, Henry Edgar
Sarles, J. Merritt
Sarles, James Henry
Sarles, John
Sarles, John B.
Sarles, Julia M.
Sarles, Leila May
Sarles, M. Elizabeth
Sarles, Maria
Sarles, Mary
Sarles, Mary F.
Sarles, Mortimer
Sarles, Mylon
Sarles, Nancy (1784-1825)
Sarles, Nancy (1783-1863)
Sarles, Nancy A.
Sarles, Parthenia
Sarles, Phebe W.
Sarles, Philip
Sarles, Samuel
Sarles, Sarah Elizabeth
Sarles, Sarah G. Mosher
Sarles, Schuyler
Sarles, Seely
Sarles, Squire
Sarles, Stanley W.
Sarles, Tartullus
Sarles, Theodore (1799-1856)
Sarles, Theodore (1837-1839)
Sarles, Theodore G.
Sarles, Thomas
Sarles, Thomas E. (1836-1869)
Sarles, Thomas G.
Sarles, Thomas H.
Sarles, William
Sarles, Wilson Henry
Sarles, Mary E.
Schesler, Annett Cronk
Seaman, Charles L.
Seaman, Eunice
Seaman, Obidiah
Searles, Lydia A. (moved to Oakwood Cemetery)
Searles, Lyman W. (buried in Oakwood Cemetery)
See, G. A.
Shamp, Ann M.
Sherwood, Abram
Sherwood, Anna Augusta
Sherwood, Annie Augusta
Sherwood, Clayton E.
Sherwood, Mary Frances
Sherwood, Matilda K. Sands
Sherwood, Rev. Daniel W.
Slagle, Abraham
Slagle, Elizabeth
Smith, Albert R.
Smith, Charlotte T.
Smith, Fannie Jane
Smith, Henrietta
Smith, Morris C.
Smith, Salena
Smith, Seraphin
Stanton, Annie
Stanton, Emily
Stanton, James P.
Stanton, Jemima
Stokem, Isaac W.
Stokem, Matilda Ann
Swain, Hattie Vail

T
Taylor, Ann 
Thorn, Abby Jane
Thorn, Charles (reburied in Kensico Cemetery in 1907)
Thorn, George
Thorn, Harriet B.
Thorn, Hattie B.
Thorn, Stephen (1811-1891)
Thorn, Stephen (1852-1852)
Thorn, Susan
Thorn, William
Thorn, J. Lewis
Thorne, Theodore
Tompkins, Adelia
Tompkins, Elizabeth Ann
Tompkins, Emeline Cornelia Mead
Tompkins, Franklin B.
Tompkins, Gilbert H.
Tompkins, Mahalia
Tompkins, Mary Jane
Tripp, Lewis
Tripp, Martha B.
Tripp, Ruth A.
Tripp, Sarah L.
Tripp, Willie H.
Tyler, Abigail S. Brundage
Tyler, Gilbert Henry
Tyler, Henry D.

U

V 
Van Tassel, Anna Maria
Van Tassel, Ardelia C.
Van Tassel, Gilbert
Van Winkle, Frances Thorn

W
Washburn, Jesse E.
Washburn, C. H. Purdy
Washburn, Edith S.
Webb, Caroline
Webb, Charles H.
Webb, Hannah
Webb, Mary L.
Weeks, Joshua
Weeks, Sarah
White, Elizabeth
Whiting, Marcus
Wickson, Dorcas
Wilkes, Mary Ann
Williamson, John V.
Williamson, Julia E.
Williamson, Mary E.
Williamson, Mary J.
Williamson, Robert
Wood, Elisa
Woolsey, Jonathan (1783-1826)
Woolsey, Jonathan (1826-1855)
Woolsey, Joseph B.
Woolsey, Susan Emily
Wright, Anna
Wright, George Henry Seaman
Wright, Hannah W. Searles
Wright, Harriet Maria Seaman
Wright, James
Wright, Jesse
Wright, Lester Seaman
Wright, Lewis T.
Wright, Louis Seaman
Wright, Nathaniel
Wright, Robert
Wright, Samuel Serles
Wright, Sarah B. Seaman
Wright, Thomas

X

Y 
Yeamans, Mary Elizabeth
Yerks, Anthony
Yerks, Derinda
Yerks, James
Yerks, Mary (1802-1857)
Yerks, Mary (1821-1881)
Yerks, Mary L.
Yerks, Sarah

Z
Zarr, Jesse

Adapted from William Applebie Eaderley and Robert B. Miller's 1905/1909 transcription.