1867 Map

Here's one more map, from the 1867 Beers atlas. That little building next to the church is still there, and identified as the parsonage of the Methodist Episcopal Church. The Methodist Church itself, built in the 1840s, is beside it.

From this and the other two maps we know that that little building stood from at least 1867 to 1881, making it the likely source of much of the domestic refuse we found in the back of the cemetery.